• Plans
    Back
    • Plans for Me + My Family
      Life Insurance
      •   GVUL notice for new business
      •   Life Plan Comparison
      •   What is Life Insurance?
      •   Which Plan may be Right For You?
      •   CPA Life
      •   Spouse Life
      •   Level Premium Term Life Insurance
      •   Spouse Level Premium Term
      •   Group Variable Universal Life
      Long Term Disability
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   What it covers
      •   NEW APP
      •   Why CPAs need it
      •   What is Long Term Disability Insurance
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Long Term Disability
      •   Who is eligible for Long Term Disability?
      Identity Theft
      •   About the Provider
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Identity Theft Protection
      •   Why do CPAs select it
      •   What is Identity Theft Protection
      •   What It Costs
      •   Eligibility
      Auto/Vehicle
      •   About the Carrier
      •   What it covers
      •   Why do CPAs select it?
      •   What is Auto Insurance?
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Auto Insurance
      •   Eligibility
      Health Insurance
      •   About the Platform
      •   What it provides
      •   Why CPAs need it
      •   What is Health Insurance
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose Stride Health
      •   Eligibility
      Homeowners Insurance
      •   About the Carrier
      •   What it covers
      •   Why do CPAs select it
      •   What is Homeowners Insurance?
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Homeowners Insurance
      •   Eligibility
      Long-Term Care
      •   Long Term Care - National Thank you
      Medicare Supplement
      Renters Insurance
      •   About the Carrier
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs select it
      •   What is Renters Insurance?
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Renters Insurance
      •   Eligibility
      Personal Liability Umbrella
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   Eligibility
      •   What is Personal Liability Umbrella?
      •   What it covers
      •   What it costs
      •   Why CPAs Need It
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Personal Liability Umbrella
      View All
    • Plans for My Firm
      Professional Liability
      •   CNA Disclosure
      •   Professional Liability for Small Firms
      •   Professional Liability Premier Plan
      •   Professional Liability for Large Firms
      •   What is Professional Liability?
      •   AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program
      •   Which plan is right for your firm?
      •   Plan Cards
      Employment Practices Liability
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   Group Identify Theft Contact Us
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs select it?
      •   What is Employment Practices Liability?
      •   What it costs
      •   Why firms choose AICPA Employment Practices Liability
      •   Eligibility
      Cyber Liability
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs select it?
      •   What is a Cyber Liability endorsement?
      •   What it costs
      •   Why CPAs choose supplemental cyber liability endorsements
      •   Eligibility
      Business Overhead Expense
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs need it
      •   What is Business Overhead Expense (BOE) Insurance
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Business Overhead Expense (BOE) Insurance
      •   Who is eligible for BOE Insurance
      Commercial Property and Liability
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   What is Commercial Property and Liability?
      •   What It costs
      •   What it covers
      •   Why CPAs choose Commercial Property and Liability
      •   Why do CPAs need it
      Group Life and Disability
      •   What Firms Need to Know
      •   Group Life under 25 employees
      •   Group life 25 or more employees
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   What it covers
      •   What is Group Insurance
      •   What it costs
      •   Why CPA Firms choose AICPA Group Life Insurance
      •   Who is eligible for Group Elite Insurance
      Group Personal Excess Liability
      •   About the Underwriter
      •   Eligibility
      •   What is Group Personal Excess Liability?
      •   What it covers
      •   Why firms select it
      •   Why firms choose Group Personal Excess Liability
      Specialty Coverage
      •   About the Provider
      •   What it covers
      •   Why do CPAs need it
      •   What It Costs
      •   Why CPAs choose AICPA Specialty Coverage
      •   Eligibility
      View All
    • Plans for My Retirement
      Life Insurance
      Medicare Supplement
      •   Why do CPAs need it
      •   What is Supplemental Health Insurance in Retirement?
      Long-Term Care
      Personal Liability Umbrella
      View All
  • Education & Resources
    Back
    • Me & My Family
      Auto tips
      •   5 Tips to Follow After a Car Accident
      •   How does inflation affect insurance rates?
      •   Taking a Safe Road Trip During COVID-19 Times
      •   5 reasons your car insurance rate changes
      •   Safe Driving Tips
      COVID-19
      •   Applying for AICPA life insurance during COVID-19 can be safe, easy and done without a medical exam
      •   Personal Liability in the Age of COVID-19
      •   What can we do to protect our digital health against coronavirus?
      Disability insurance tips
      •   7 Reasons Why Applying for Disability Insurance When You’re In Your 20s or 30s is a Smart Choice.
      •   5 reasons CPAs don't have disability insurance and why they should reconsider
      •   Frequently asked questions about getting life and disability insurance answered.
      •   Disability Insurance Needs Estimator
      •   Most common causes of disabilities and how to prevent them
      •   3 Steps to Help Reduce Risk for Disability
      •   Three Big Reasons To Check Your LTD Plan
      •   Three steps to take when planning to return to work after a disability
      •   Why young people need disability insurance
      Financial Wellness
      Health tips
      •   How Much Sugar is Hiding in Your Food?
      •   7 Steps to Jumpstart Healthy Habits
      •   What’s Cooking? Dine in with a Healthy Plan
      •   How to Conquer Tax Season
      •   How to stay healthy during times of uncertainty
      •   Most common causes of disabilities and how to prevent them
      •   One of the Most Important Steps You Can Take to Improve Your Health
      •   Vitamin D - Are you getting the right amount?
      Homeowner tips
      •   7 Tips for Holiday Home Fire Safety
      •   Home sharing and your insurance: What you need to know
      •   Moving and your home insurance
      •   How to keep your valuables safe from harm
      •   Homesharing and your insurance
      •   Step Up Your Holiday Home Safety with These Important Tips
      Identity Theft tips
      •   Are Children at Risk of Identity Theft?
      •   Risk Alert: The Rise of Unemployment Fraud – What You Need to Know
      •   Risk Alert: Identity Theft and Unemployment Insurance Claims
      •   Help Protect Your Identity While on Vacation
      •   COVID-19 Scams - What You Need to Know
      •   Work From Home Cybersecurity Tips
      Life insurance tips
      •   The AICPA Insurance Trust: 75 years of helping to protect members and their loved ones.
      •   Choose reliability, not luck when planning your financial future
      •   Do you have enough life insurance for your stage in life?
      •   Answers to life insurance questions you have (but are too afraid to ask).
      •   Discover the enhanced Level Premium Term Insurance Plan
      •   5 Reasons to Apply for Life Insurance When You’re Young
      •   Now Is the Perfect Time to Help Protect Your Loved Ones
      •   How life insurance can help pay for educational expenses.
      •   The importance of having enough Life Insurance
      •   If your spouse died today, would you be prepared?
      •   Just Married? Plan for Your Future with Life Insurance
      •   Level Premium Term (LPT) Life Explained
      •   Life Insurance in a Nutshell
      •   Experience life’s ups and downs with premiums that stay the same
      •   Looking for lower life insurance rates
      •   Help protect your firm’s most valuable asset—your employees
      •   Frequently asked questions about getting life and disability insurance answered.
      •   Life Insurance Needs Estimator
      •   The importance of life insurance for every woman.
      •   What to know about Creating a Will
      •   Why It’s Important to Name a Beneficiary
      •   Keep moving forward throughout every stage of life.
      Personal liability tips
      •   Assess Your Personal Liability Risk
      •   Quick Answers to CPA’s Questions about Personal Liability Umbrella Insurance
      •   Why CPAs Need Personal Liability Umbrella Insurance
      •   Umbrella Liability Insurance: Protection for Your Retirement
      Planning for retirement
      •   Umbrella Liability Insurance: Protection for Your Retirement
      •   What to know about Creating a Will
      •   Why women should include long-term care in their retirement strategy
      VIEW ALL
    • My Firm
      Acceptance, Continuance and Termination
      •   Unresponsive Clients Pose a Professional Liability Risk
      •   Client acceptance: A liability gatekeeper
      •   Client continuance: A life vest for risky clients
      •   Frequently asked risk management questions
      •   The Importance of Gauging Client's Tone at the Top
      •   Take a Hike: Ending Client Relationships
      •   Client Termination Letters
      •   Small actions, big fallout: Lessons from large claims
      Accounting & Consulting Services
      •   Risk Control in Outsourced Accounting Services
      •   Managing risk related to consulting engagements
      •   Minding the Expectation Gap in a CAS Engagement
      •   CPAs as CFO: meeting client needs, managing the risks
      •   Remember to Plan for Risk
      Audit & Attest Services
      •   Independence is in the Eye of the Beholder
      •   A Framework for Maintaining Ethics Compliance
      •   The risk suite: This teenager can mitigate liability angst
      •   The Importance of Audit Planning
      •   Advice from the experts: Defending audit claims
      •   An Auditor's Dilemma: To Consent or Not to Consent?
      •   There’s No Substitute for Quality
      Benefits
      •   Key Benchmarks for CPA Firms
      •   Help protect your firm’s most valuable asset—your employees
      •   Tax Benefits of Long-Term Care Insurance
      •   New to Buying Group Life Insurance?
      COVID-19
      •   COVID-19 Insights & Resources
      •   COVID-19 Vaccine & Mental Health
      •   Risk Alert: Round Two – Paycheck Protection Program Loan Application Assistance and Forgiveness App
      •   Risk Alert: “COVID Homes” Create Professional Liability Risk for CPA Firms
      •   Growing Trends: 3 Risk Areas for Employers in 2020
      •   Risk Alert Toolkit Workplace Safety
      •   The indirect impacts of COVID-19 on CPA Firms
      •   Risk Alert: Coronavirus and Business Continuity
      •   Risk Alert: COVID-19 and Return to Work
      •   Risk Alert: Data Security Considerations to Help Weather a Pandemic
      •   COVID-19 Scams - What You Need to Know
      •   Weekly Workplace Safety: 5-part webcast
      •   Risk Alert: COVID-19 and the Return to Work
      CPA Risk Watch
      •   On Aon's 2022 Predictions Featuring Global Risk Experts
      •   How Professional Liability Insurance Helps Protect CPA Firms
      •   How to Help Reduce Your Professional Liability Risk This Tax Season
      Data Security Risk Management
      •   Don’t get victimized by a cybercriminal
      •   4 Steps to better Cybersecurity
      •   Responding to Client Requests for Confidentiality
      •   Social Engineering: Is Your CPA Firm Protected?
      •   Crime Coverage Highlight Sheet
      •   Employee & Cybercriminal Theft: Should CPAs be Concerned?
      •   Cyber liability: Managing evolving exposures​​
      •   A cyber-attack could spell disaster for your CPA firm
      •   CPA firms, Ben Franklin and a moth; Cyber Risk Mitigation Fundamentals
      •   Cybersecurity: A top concern among accounting professionals
      •   Doing Business in the Cloud? Carry an Umbrella.
      •   Risk Alert: Risks Associated with New York SHIELD Act
      •   Professional Liability Risks Related to Cloud Computing
      •   The armor of awareness
      •   Controlling your data
      •   The Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act and Business Associates
      Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)
      •   Five Key Areas to Focus
      •   Inclusive Future of Work : Are Inclusion and Diversity Part of Your Benefits and Retirement Program?
      •   CPA Spotlight September 2021
      •   CPA Spotlight July 2021
      •   CPA Spotlight March 2021
      •   CPA Spotlight February 2021
      •   Aon’s Lisa Stevens on shaping the modern workforce
      •   Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in the Workplace
      Employment Practices
      •   Tread Carefully When Using Noncompete Agreements
      •   Addressing third-party discrimination or harassment
      •   Employment Practices Liability Claim Scenarios
      •   Employment Practices Legal Hotline
      •   Growing Trends: 3 Risk Areas for Employers in 2020
      VIEW ALL
    • My Retirement
      Homeowner tips
      •   How to keep your valuables safe from harm
      Identity Theft tips
      •   Help Protect Your Identity While on Vacation
      •   Medicare Fraud – Protect Yourself and Medicare
      Life Insurance Tips
      •   Keep moving forward throughout every stage of life.
      •   How could life insurance fit into your retirement plan?
      •   Looking for lower life insurance rates
      •   Why It’s Important to Name a Beneficiary
      Long-term Care Tips
      •   Navigating the Ever-Changing World of Long-Term Care Insurance Solutions
      •   As Cost of Long-Term Care Increases Know your Options
      •   Do you have a strategy for caregiving?
      •   Millennials face additional challenges as caregivers
      •   Preparing for long-term care during a time of loss
      •   Why women should include long-term care in their retirement strategy
      Medicare Tips
      •   Medicare Fraud – Protect Yourself and Medicare
      •   The Advantages of Your Medicare Supplement
      Personal Liability Tips
      •   Assess Your Personal Liability Risk
      •   Umbrella Liability Insurance: Protection for Your Retirement
      Planning for Retirement
      •   Investing in Turbulent Times: The Impact of the Coronavirus
      •   Retirement Planning Tools
      •   Navigating the Ever-Changing World of Long-Term Care Insurance Solutions
      •   The Advantages of Your Medicare Supplement
      •   The Advantages of Your Medicare Supplement
      •   Umbrella Liability Insurance: Protection for Your Retirement
      VIEW ALL
  • About
    Back
  • Contact
    Back
    CPAI Logo
     Search
    X
     My Account
    Log In
    Choose which policy type you need to manage
    Personal Insurance Policyholders
    Professional Liability Policyholders
    Group Life Plan Policyholders
    View All My Account
    Print Friendly

    Navigating storms, and risk, with subcontractors

    By Matt Mitzen, CPA, and Deborah K. Rood, CPA
    Download PDF

    Like any good sea captain, many CPA firms run a tight ship, ensuring staff are appropriately utilized and busy delivering client service. While this staffing model makes sense most of the year, there are times when not having enough hands on deck may sink the ship. To keep the boat afloat, firms often engage outside help to assist during stormier times, such as tax season, or to provide expertise that does not otherwise reside within the firm, such as engagement quality control review (EQCR) services. While using subcontractors has the advantage of just-in-time staffing, there are professional liability risks to consider.
    An example of such a risk is shown in the following claim scenario:

    A CPA firm engaged a subcontractor who was winding down his own tax practice to assist with the firm’s April 15 tax deadline. Unbeknownst to the firm, the subcontractor also provided bill payment services on behalf of his legacy clients. In addition, he started providing these services for the firm’s clients assigned to him, without its knowledge. After April 15, the subcontractor’s services for the firm ended, but the firm did not inform its clients of the termination. The subcontractor continued to make payments on the clients’ behalf. The firm only realized this when it was sued by a client for the subcontractor’s embezzlement of over $3 million from the client. The client asserted that it believed the subcontractor was still acting on behalf of the firm and that the firm failed to supervise the actions of its “agent.”
     
    As the story demonstrates, the actions of a firm’s subcontractors, even though they are unrelated third parties of a CPA firm, can place the firm at risk. Consider implementing the tips below to mitigate the risk of a claim related to subcontractors.
     

    BATTEN DOWN THE HATCHES

    Before setting sail, revisit your needs. Are you looking for additional crew to prepare income tax returns during March and April, or are you looking for someone with specific talents, such as international or state and local tax expertise?
    Irrespective of the role a subcontractor will play, perform due diligence to evaluate the subcontractor just as you would a new employee. Is the subcontractor qualified in the required areas? Can the subcontractor perform the required functions? Consider a busy CPA who hastily engaged a subcontractor on a Friday afternoon in late February to help prepare international aspects of corporate tax returns, prior to completing due diligence. After providing client information for the subcontractor to work on at his home office, the CPA discovered that the subcontractor had misrepresented his experience and did not have the necessary knowledge. The relationship was immediately terminated, but significant time was spent determining if all client information was returned, as well as reviewing and completing in-process work. Ultimately, the firm was left with no assistance in preparing the tax returns.

    When engaging subcontractors, remember to:
    • Ensure subcontractor professional licenses are valid and current;
    • Evaluate the skills and experience of the subcontractor by checking references and performing other procedures to assess qualifications;
    • Evaluate the subcontractor’s cybersecurity practices;
    • Confirm the subcontractor is in good standing with the AICPA and state CPA society;
    • Address where services will be performed, including how information will be shared between the CPA firm and the subcontractor;
    • Review the subcontractor’s peer review report, if applicable; and
    • Examine continuing professional education to determine its relevance to the firm’s requirements.

    Importantly, ask why this person has capacity at a busy time of the year. Some subcontractors may have difficulty working with others, preventing them from having a full client list or holding a full-time position. Another red flag is a subcontractor who has jumped from firm to firm over several years.
     

    PREPARE TO SET SAIL

    Before beginning any client work, the CPA firm obtains an engagement letter. Likewise, a written agreement also should be executed with the subcontractor. Some professional liability insurers and other third-party providers have samples.
    While the subcontractor agreement is similar to a client engagement letter, significant differences should be addressed, including:
    • The subcontractor’s responsibilities regarding the protection of confidential client information and their responsibilities in the event of a data security incident;
    • Training to be provided by the CPA firm;
    • Documentation and maintenance of professional and cyber liability insurance by both the CPA firm and the subcontractor;
    • The subcontractor’s indemnification of the CPA firm for claims brought against the CPA firm as a result of the subcontractor’s gross negligence or intentional misconduct;
    • The CPA firm’s responsibility to direct, supervise, review, and evaluate the subcontractor’s work; and
    • The CPA firm’s responsibility for the final deliverable, including any conclusions reached.

    Clearly delineating roles and responsibilities between the parties is important. For example, will EQCR comments be cleared by the subcontractor or the engagement partner? If the engagement partner clears review points, does the engagement partner understand the concerns raised by the subcontractor? If the subcontractor prepares tax returns, is there a designated firm representative who must review and sign the returns prepared by the subcontractor before they are filed?
    How and when will the subcontractor receive training on firm methodology, systems, or technical updates relevant to the services to be delivered? A CPA firm’s processes, procedures, and tools help ensure the firm provides a consistent, high quality deliverable to its clients. Having all parties rowing in the same direction is a key factor in the potential success of a firmsubcontractor relationship.
     

    MAINTAIN AN EVEN KEEL

    Supervising experienced professionals may create choppy waters, but all firm personnel should be monitored. The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (ET §0.300.060.06) requires CPAs to “plan and supervise adequately any professional activity for which he or she is responsible.” Supervise subcontractors as you would any new hire performing similar services.
    What should you do if the subcontractor specializes in an area in which the firm has limited or no expertise? Regardless of the firm’s knowledge in the specific subject matter, it should have sufficient experience to define the work and review the work product and determine if it is reasonable. If the subcontractor’s work does not appear to be reasonable, and the explanation provided is not sufficient, keep probing until it is. The CPA firm should understand the work performed and the conclusions reached in order to approve and issue the final work product. The subcontractor should also provide documentation to support the work performed and conclusions reached, which is then retained by the CPA firm.
     

    PREPARE FOR PIRATES

    Remember the “inexperienced” subcontractor noted earlier? That subcontractor was hired to work from his home and had access to clients’ personal information. Even if the subcontractor was honorable, such information could be inadvertently disclosed to others sharing the contractor’s workspace. Or a miscreant may have the ability to access information if the subcontractor does not have appropriate data security safeguards in place. What security protocols do they use? Will they use your firm’s VPN (virtual private network)? The article “Professional Liability Spotlight: Due Diligence With CPA Firm Subcontractors,” JofA, June 2015, discusses a firm’s legal and professional responsibilities related to subcontractors.
     

    ALL ABOARD

    There are both upsides and potential risks to using a subcontractor. If you are the subcontractor, the same considerations noted above apply, except you are keeping an eye open for a potential employer. Are you ready, willing, and able to be a deckhand reporting to a new captain? If not, this could create little ripples that become big swells on the voyage to a smooth busy season.

    Matt Mitzen, CPA, CFE, and  Deborah K. Rood, CPA, are risk control consulting directors at CNA. For more information about this article, contact specialtyriskcontrol@cna.com.
    Continental Casualty Company, one of the CNA insurance companies, is the underwriter of the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program. Aon Insurance Services, the National Program Administrator for the AICPA Professional Liability Program, is available at 800-221-3023 or visit cpai.com.
    This article provides information, rather than advice or opinion. It is accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge as of the article date. This article should not be viewed as a substitute for recommendations of a retained professional. Such consultation is recommended in applying this material in any particular factual situations.
    Examples are for illustrative purposes only and not intended to establish any standards of care, serve as legal advice, or acknowledge any given factual situation is covered under any CNA insurance policy. The relevant insurance policy provides actual terms, coverages, amounts, conditions, and exclusions for an insured. All products and services may not be available in all states and may be subject to change without notice.

     

    To learn more, please visit cpai.com or call 800.221.3023

    Related Products

    Professional Liability
    Professional Liability
    Learn More

    Assistance with the associated legal and defense fees in the event of a lawsuit for errors and omissions.

    Management Liability for CPA Firms
    Employment Practices Liability Endorsement
    Learn More
    An Employment Practices Liability endorsement added to your Professional Liability policy helps provide a defense and pay for expenses related to claims alleging a wrongful employment practice.  
    logo
    logo

    AICPA Member Insurance Programs
    1100 Virginia Drive, Suite 250
    Fort Washington, PA 19034

    Plans

    • Me & My Family
    • My Firm
    • My Retirement

    Education + Resources

    • Me & My Family
    • My Firm
    • My Retirement

    Legal

    • About Us
    • Privacy Notice
    • Insurance License Information

    Quick Links

    • Contact Us
    • My Account
    • eRisk Hub
    • AICPA Annual Cash Refund
    • CPA Risk Report sign-up
    • Policyholder Resource Center for Professional Liability